10x high-rated eyeliners, approved by Eves members, that will create the perfect wing All reviews are by real people - here, we do not entertain bots or fakes, just raw-and-real user experiences, for more conscious beauty buying!
Are you looking for the best eyeliner to create an eyeliner look? We have 10x high rated eyeliners for you. From the precision of an eyeliner pencil to the smooth lines of a liquid eyeliner and the sultry allure of a gel eyeliner, we've got them all. And for those unpredictable moments, our waterproof eyeliners are here to stay. Whether you're on the hunt for the best liquid eyeliner or simply exploring eyeliner artistry, get ready to explore a world of eye-popping options. We're sharing those that rated the highest, earning them a stamp of approval from our Eves community.
Get the perfect wing with the best liquid liner?
favourite eyeliner ever
wear it almost every day
doesn't smudge
easy to apply
lasts quite a while so even though i use it almost every single day multiple times i only have to get a new one around once a month and it is affordable so price is good for what it is
The finest eyeliner there is. Stays very well in place and is a fine brush to apply the eyeliner.
Perfect to apply. It is very easy and stays in place. For me personally, I would rather go for brown due to my white and light hair color.
Beautiful deep black color and with 1 line already opaque. Thanks to the fine tip, you can put beautiful clean lines in one strip perfectly. True addition to this eyeliner! #maxfactor #eyeliner
Beautiful deep black, can (with some practice) set beautiful lines with it and stays in place all day long without smearing or fading! @maxfactor
The Max Factor's High Precision Liquid Eyeliner is hailed as a must-have for those seeking precision and intense pigmentation. Its fine brush applicator glides effortlessly across the lid, allowing for precise lines and dramatic eye looks. Members love its long-lasting formula that doesn't smudge or fade, making it perfect for all-day wear.
Eyeliner wings? Let's go!
Normally, I use the Kat von D tattoo liner, my favorite! Unfortunately, it is not for sale in the Netherlands, but I have to go to Germany every time.
Unfortunately, I ran out of eyeliner and I had to wait another month to go to Germany. That's why I started looking for a new eyeliner.
I tried multiple eyeliners, NYX, Kylie, Lancôme, maybeline, but it was all terrible. Dyed out quickly and crumbled or sat on my eyelid.
This benefit eyeliner is really amazing, it stays in place, is mega black and doesn't dry out! A bit more expensive than kat von d, but I'm willing to do it if that's not an option.
I love this eyeliner. As you can see in the video, I create a simple line in just 30 seconds. It works easily, has a good black color and stays in place. Even a sweaty 5 minute basketball workout is no match for this liner, because it hasn't been smudged or disappeared during training. However, you can easily remove it with a cleansing oil or miscellar water. Ideal!
* I am surprised by its very precise outline, in general I am not good at applying the liner my line has never been as precise and easy to draw as with this one. The brush delivers just the right amount of ink and dries quickly. It is flexible according to your desires, you can make all kinds of more or less thick lines and let your imagination run wild. It offers a kind of feeling of lightness, you completely forget that you are wearing makeup.
myself
* I really like the packaging with its original shape and striking colors that are out of the ordinary.
away
* What I also like is that it does not flow, it lasts all day even after exercising and perspiring, it will be great for summer even with the heat and perspiration. I rubbed my eye at one point I was afraid I had crumbled everything but it remained intact so it keeps its promise, it does not crumble and does not transfer onto fingers or clothing.
away
* The fact that it is waterproof does not make it more difficult to remove makeup, a cotton/makeup remover and there is nothing left, it also does not stain my washable makeup remover discs, it is effortless to wash.
away
• A great innovation from the brand that I recommend. Hope it will last me a long time...
away
• What I didn't like the most was its satin finish.
Got to test it thanks to this site and@benefit
I've never been good with using liquid liner but it's super easy to use thanks to the felt-tip. I did this look after 1 try and that's pretty good for me! It also stays in place and is super black.
It is very well pigmented, I only have to draw 1 line and immediately it's good!! @benefiteven after a few days of use, I'm still a fan! If my product runs out, I will definitely buy a new one. I also bought one for my daughter.
According to the honest reviews, this liner is perfect for creating a quick cat-eye. And the deep black color lasts all day (and night), say Eves members! Prepare for some extreme precision with the Benefit They're Real! Xtreme Precision Liner. Members can't get enough of its innovative eyeliner tip, which allows for effortless control and ultra-fine lines. This eyeliner is a game-changer for achieving precise, defined eyes with ease. Say hello to bold, long-lasting looks that won't let you down.
This is how Kylie creates that gel eyeliner look
I use very little makeup but I never found a good one. I like it and it stays super long and beautiful in color. And is easy to apply. Never expected him to be good but it's really good. I really recommend it, you won't regret it.
Really by far the best eye pencil I've ever used. The pencil has a nice packaging and you can sharpen it. You take a very long time with the pencil so it's definitely worth the price as the quality is great. Many makeup products are smudge proof, but this one is bizarre smudge proof. You can rub whatever you want but this line really doesn't go anywhere! Because you can sharpen it sharply, you can draw a tight line with possibly a wing that will undoubtedly stay in place for as long as you want. The pencil is not dry at all, so you can draw a line easily and smoothly. For novice eye pencil users, it might be a little too smooth that makes you shoot faster, that's the only thing I have to say about the product. But for experienced eye pencil users, this is an extra advantage!
Super nice pencil! Color is nice, dark but because it is a dark brown color is much softer than black. The formula of the pencil is also soft and you can replace it nicely and blend it with your eyeshadow look. The packaging is also very nice. Recommended!
I absolutely love this eyeliner. I received the frosted brown one. It is extremely pigmented (very dark brown). The pencil glides very creamy over the skin, but after a few seconds it dries up after which it is no longer fading. I've tried it on my water line so far. Normally I have that my eyeliner stains very quickly because I often have tear eyes, but with this eyeliner I didn't have that and it stayed for hours! If you put an eyeliner wing with it and want to smudge it, you have to work fast, because the pencil dries up quickly. That means it stays in place all day! I was afraid that taking it off with makeup would be very difficult, but this went off easily with eye makeup remover. So I would especially recommend this pencil if you really suffer from tear anos/lenses, because if it doesn't bother you, it is of course a pricey product. The pencil itself is very easy to sharpen, please note that you have to have a pencil sharpener at home because it is not included! Furthermore, the amount of product contained in it is also sufficient, about the same amount as other pencils. @kyliner @kylie
Really nice eye pencil. I had the blue one. It has a kind of glitter, very nice. It applies very easily, you don't have to go over your eyelid several times before you really see something, but it's an intense color right away. I really think it's more of an eye pencil, applying as an eyeliner is very difficult. It also stays in place really well. He sat on it all day long and did not fade. Even after the shower, it was still there. It doesn't say if it's waterproof, but I think it's really waterproof. It stays in place very well.
You've probably seen it on Insta or TikTok, but this eyeliner is also a real hype on We Are Eves. And Eves members have already tried it and are enthusiastic!
Want your wings sharp and extra black? This is it!
One of my previous posts already stated that I ordered from a new website (5th glow) for me. I was so happy that my favorite foundation was still available here and immediately stocked up on some fun stuff.
I also received a sample from Maybelline in my package. The Maybelline masterpreciseallday liquid liner, to be precise.
The liner is super fast and precise and beautifully pigmented in black. The tip is fine and precise and the liner itself is easy to hold. Once set, the liner stays beautiful for a long time, even if, like me, you often sit on the eyes and lashes. (I always think there's something in my eye). By the way, the photos were taken at the end of the day so that's how good the eyeliner is. Furthermore, easy to remove with misccelar remover.
Very happy with this sample and I definitely think I would buy this eyeliner. Nice that pink has been added to the liquid liner, so this eyeliner is also easy to find among the other makeup.
Very good product.I was delighted with the result.I used the MAC brand for a long time... while this product has the same quality and it is more accessible (+- 10€ less) So choose courageously this product that will do the trick.Thank you
my fave eyeliner!! searched far and wide for the perfect eyeliner, one that dosent have too much product on the applicator but many cant pick up enough!! this does it all for me, easy application, sharp edges and the packaging feels luxurious. as an eyeliner gal this is my new best friend 🫶🏻
I recommend this product! The very fine tip allows you to make beautiful and extremely precise makeup!
In addition, it stays all day and does not sink!!
Its use is very simple. I recommend this liner, it is one of the bathroom essentials!
This product meets my expectations and it keeps its promises. It is very opaque, it does not flow and it lasts a long time. It fits easily in the hand and the tip glides well over the eyelid. It is an eyeliner that I recommend. It's a good quality/price ratio
Get ready to master drama with the Maybelline Eyeliner Master Drama Precis Liquid Liner. Members praise its intense black color and smooth application. Its unique Precision Brush glides effortlessly, allowing for both thin and thick lines with precision. This eyeliner is a staple for creating eye-catching, smudge-proof looks. Want a super sharp wing? According to Eves-members, this liquid eyeliner is all you need! And it is budget-proof too.
This is how you create an eyeliner look!
This eyeliner is so underrated. It’s my favourite out of all the eyeliner I’ve used before. The liner itself is like a thin brush pen but the applicator makes it easier to apply liner on my hooded eyes in comparison to a paintbrush like liner end. The shape is perfect and the applicator is the right wetness. I say this because often with eyeliners I find them too wet, or smudgy, or hard to apply especially on very hooded eyes. Love this eyeliner so much.
For 6 years straight this has been one of the very few products i use on a daily basis. Nothing beats it, call it the beast of eyeliners if you may! It does not budge from my face at all. I used to work in a leisure centre and it survived 35-40 degrees celsius and not get all smudged!
I wear eyeliner everyday, religiously over any other product. So I am always on the hunt for one which is quick and smooth in its application, and this is it. It’s a true black and lasts for me all day long, easy to apply and allows the perfect shape wing. My new favourite and I would love to give the brown a try too
Benefit's Roller Liner in brown is my favorite product ever. I've been using these for a long time. Compared to the black color, in my opinion, it stays better in the inner corner, for example. It is a very nice, not too flexible pen tip. This makes application very easy
I haven't been using Benefit's black roller liner that long. Compared to the brown one, it may not be completely smudgeproof. I can also apply it to my inner corner as a liner but it didn't stay in place here. For the rest, as a wing, it stays in place all day long, and you can easily update it if you've made a mistake. Removal can be done with micellar water or other cleaning agents
Eves members have already tried this eyeliner and are HYPED! According to the honest reviews, this eyeliner fits comfortably in the hand and your winged liner stays in place all day long, without fading!
This liquid eyeliner is a multitasker
After a long search, I finally found a nice replacement for the Kat von D tattoo liner. I really like this eyeliner, sets nice clean lines and is really deep black. Had to get used to the tip because you can use it in 2 ways, thick and thin. If you're used to that, it's ideal!
Are you going for a thin, sharp line or a dramatic effect? The
NARS Climax Liquid Eyeliner can be used in two different ways thanks to the thin and thick side of the pen. And the liner is intensely black in color, according to Eves members.
Go for a cat eye with this liquid eyeliner pencil
I know this eyeliner is not to everyone's tastes due to the bristle brush, but for me it is perfect. I find creating precise wings and tight lines so much easier with this kind of brush. I prefer this type of brush to the felt tip type of applicator which is more commonly used. For anyone who finds this type of brush hard to use, it can take practice and (a lot of) patience. The eyeliner dries with a slightly glossy finish, and like paint once it is dry it is not possible for it to smudge. To remove it you can also peel it off whilst washing your face, so no need to use makeup remover if you're in a rush.
What a lovely eyeliner! Because I have drooping eyelids, my eyeliner always sticks to the top. This does not bother me at all with this eyeliner. Can draw very fine lines with this so that nothing sticks to the top. I can definitely recommend this eyeliner for everyone. Stays in place all day long.
I like to use liquid eyeliner for a cat-eye effect, so I bought this eyeliner in dark brown.
Unlike other eyeliners, it doesn't shed, it stays in place all day long! even when I'm cycling through the rain, when it's not even waterproof!
It is a very nice brush so I can easily make a thin line.
I will definitely buy this eyeliner again, I enjoy it all day long and I can also easily remove it with an oil-based remover.
I also didn't get irritated eyes, which I sometimes have with other eyeliners.
Personally, eyeliner is very important to me. It's really hard to find an eyeliner that's really good black - but that's this one! He stays seated all day and the best part is that he doesn't smudge. I have hooded eyes, and he won't stick to them. It is also easy to remove the eyeliner, it kind of grains off. Top product!
This eyeliner is very nice, nice to use and nice in terms of stripe. The brush is very thin but not too thin, you can make thin stripes with it but if you press a little harder, you get thicker.
The color is beautiful black, not faint and lasts a long time. The brush cap also feels comfortable in my hand, I have the idea that I can straighten a line faster than with other eyeliners. (because I don't have a steady hand) but it went pretty smoothly with this eyeliner. Thank you @bourjois @weareeves for letting me test this eyeliner.
A liquid eyeliner that doesn't stick or fade? According to honest reviews, this liner is perfect for creating a sleek cat eye. Even Eves members who normally like to use an eyeliner pencil are enthusiastic about this pencil!
A razor-sharp eyeliner for a very small price?
This product works very well for me, it lasts a long time and is easy to apply with the brush in the eyeliner. I recommend this product because it is smudge proof and therefore lasts a long time. The price-quality ratio is top... a top product for little money
My all-time favorite eyeliner!
if you have no experience, it takes some getting used to, because there is a thin brush. But you can really go in any direction with this. A thin wing, a larger wing. The eyeliner is also really waterproof and stays in place very well.
It comes at a small price and I've been happy with it for years.
Well, this is and will remain my eyeliner foreverrr
Is better than all the eyeliners brands on the market, is just the champion vannde liners.
Super satisfied with, is easy, certainly does not run out and most important of all is waterproof
Some things don't have to be expensive! This eyeliner is my favorite and I have been using for years, is easy to apply and stays in place for a long time and well. Tip: put on mascara first, let it dry for a while and then put on the eyeliner.
On a budget? Eves members rave about this budget-proof and waterproof eyeliner from Essence. If we can believe the honest reviews, this eyeliner is long lasting, deep black in color and can really withstand water.
Is this the ultimate eyeliner?
I am thrilled to have found this eyeliner! Finally one that doesn't dry out quickly and is super nice and good to apply! Even over makeup. If you have a bit more budget left over for your makeup... this is the eyeliner you want if you ask me.
Review after +/- 6 months:
Best eye liner ever! I'm still using the same one and it still works great! So super sustainable ♡
This eyeliner is a breakthrough for a beautiful cat eye. The precision brush glides effortlessly across the eyelid, allowing you to apply fine lines and distinctive wings with remarkable ease. Once applied, the formula dries almost instantly, preventing transfers.
The deep, matte black color gives the eyes intense definition. I was particularly impressed with the longevity of the eyeliner. Even on the hottest, most humid days, it stayed put without blemishes. I really recommend this eyeliner!
Thanks to @weareeves & @rimmellondon
I was quite skeptical about this eyeliner, but how wrong I was! I have hooded eyes, and this eyeliner is perfect for that. Thanks to the narrow applicator, you can apply this product very precisely, and the product also dries quickly so that it does not peel off. In addition, the eyeliner also stays in place for a long time! Nice to use and does not dry out quickly, great!
Highly recommended for people with hooded eyes!
Love this eyeliner as the definition is so perfect. Stays on for hours even during workouts without smudging! I will definitely recommend this product and be purchasing it as a standard in my makeup collection. Great intensity of colour and easy to apply with soft but defined brush.
Recently I got to test this Rimmel eyeliner. In the past, I wasn't enthusiastic about these types of eyeliners. Difficult to apply and sometimes the marker did not cover all at once. I always use a kohl pencil marker myself and am very enthusiastic about it. Still, I was really curious about this eyeliner and must say it did not disappoint me. Applying it also takes some practice and keeping a cotton swab handy is so easy. I had drawn a line but it went above my eyelid, leaving me with two lines. It covers very well and because the tip is so sharp, you can draw a nice line. The ink covers very well. It stays in place all day long. At first, when applied, it felt slightly itchy, but that disappeared quickly. I will definitely buy this eyeliner again. Didn't expect to be so excited about it.
If we can believe the honest reviews, the applicator of this liner is like a kind of marker. This way you can apply a winged eyeliner super easily, as if you were drawing!
This is how you create a chic eyeliner wing
I'm a tester and I received this tester, I think it has a nice shell, the color black is exactly my color that I use every day. After putting it on, I notice that the loner to set the line is very sturdy and you can put nice eyeliner on it. The tip of the eyeliner is a bit stiff and a bit too thin to make deeper thick lines. Furthermore, fine eyeliner
I was allowed to test this
What an incredibly fine eyeliner!
You can draw a tight line with it. Update where you didn't do the right thing that's equal in both eyes.
Deleting is a quick one. Use some of your favorite makeup cleanser and go
What a lovely eyeliner this is! He does what it promises, and the structure around the eyes wow wow wow. Super nice. Great for a night out, or just at home with a snack and a drink with your husband or girlfriend. I really recommend this eyeliner to everyone.
I have two left hands. A winged eyeliner is therefore not for me..
But this changed when I got the chance to test this eyeliner.
I'm now making an almost perfect wing in a few minutes. Sure, it still needs a bit of updating, but practice makes perfect.
I am very happy with this and I will definitely buy it!!
I really liked the product: the Gucci Eyebrow Pencil works very well and defines it very nicely, it's nice that it has a sharp point. The color is also beautiful and fits my eyebrows very well. I definitely recommend it to everyone from beginner to advanced.
Are you looking for a statement piece for your beauty shelf? According to the Eves-members, this eyeliner from Gucci is more than worth the investment. It is not only long lasting, but also super beautifully pigmented, say the Eves!
High rated Eyeliners - FINAL VERDICT
Which eyeliner product suits your makeup preferences best? Are you in the market for waterproof eyeliner? An eyeliner pencil? A liquid eyeliner? —Whichever one, we're all about conscious choice here.
With WAE, upping your makeup products collection doesn't have to be complicated anymore! We are here every single week to give you the latest details, from our beauty archives, on our communities highest rated products. Meaning, saving your time, moolah, and stress just got a WHOLE lot easier.
HEY, we wanna hear from you!
If you've enjoyed reading the latest beauty reviews, why not pop in your own thoughts and officially join the We Are Eves family? Our virtual beauty gang is always ready for more raw-and-real reviews, and we wanna know what you think! Click the link below to start your journey. We've saved a space for you…