6 mascaras that are BIG favourites among Eves members All reviews are by real people - here, we do not entertain bots or fakes, just raw-and-real user experiences, for more conscious beauty buying!
Elevate your mascara game with the ultimate lash transformations. We've compiled the ultimate list of the top 6x high rated mascaras , including the best waterproof mascaras, best drugstore mascara finds. Your quest for the perfect mascara ends right here! Whether you're searching for the best mascara to achieve dreamy length or just the perfect mascara to define your lashes, we've got you covered. Your quest for the ideal mascara ends here – we've gathered the best of the best to ensure your lashes are always on point!
Best mascara on the market?!
I've really become a fan of the NARS Climax Mini Mascara in Explicit Black. Despite being a mini size, it gives my lashes plenty of volume and length without clumping. The color is intense black, which immediately gives my eyes more expression. What I especially like is that it stays in place all day without smudging or running out. Perfect for when you want a powerful look but still want to stay natural. Ideal for carrying in your bag or traveling!
Normally, I use Maybelinne mascaras every day, as these price/quality are ok. This mascara by Nars is really great! Despite the fact that the price is a bit on the higher side, it is certainly worth the added value in price. The mascara is easy to apply. In addition, you never have lumps when applying the mascara. I think you often have this with the cheaper brands. It gives you beautiful full lashes without having to apply too much product. Finally, the packaging is very nice and is a gem to add to your makeup collection! Overall, I definitely recommend this mascara!
I was on the lion for some new makeup and had a trial done at nars. The lady doing my trial used this mascara it made my lashes longer and fuller was so amazed I had to have it. It made my lashes longer and didn't feel clumpy or heavy on my lashes.i would recommend this to anyone with short lasges.
I have used this mascara for years, I have tried others and I always come back to this! I curl my lashes first l, then do 2 coats of mascara. I find it lasts all day and doesn't smudge or end up on my eyelids. The product itself lasts quiet some time and I think it's worth the money
After many mascaras, I finally found it.. Nars.. what a nice mascara, you can easily apply it in layers, no lumps, no spider legs, lashes. In the beginning, I had to get used to the brush, once in use, you don't want anything else. Recommended!
Nars Climax Mascara, adored by Eves community with an impressive 4.1 rating, is not just another mascara – it's a lash revolution in a chic black tube. Picture this: dramatic length, irresistible volume, and a smooth, clump-free finish that stays put all day. Members are swooning over its smudge-resistant formula, ability to enhance even the tiniest lashes, and the magic it brings to their makeup looks. If you've been on the quest for the ultimate mascara that delivers on all fronts, meet your new makeup BFF.
Vegan, voluminous, and long-lasting
I don't normally use mascara much, but I really like this one. Because of its brown color, it is not very noticeable but makes your eyelash just a little longer and fuller. The mascara also gives off no lumps and is easy to remove. I also really feel like my lashes are good.
If you can't stand everything, a very nice mascara. You can build layers well, gives nice volume. No lumps and you can also take them off easily in the evening! ❤️ purchased after a reaction to my old mascara and so far, my eyes and the skin around them are doing well.
Mega nice mascara! Gives your lashes a lot of volume and is easy to build up for more length.
Removing mascara from the lashes is very easy with micellar water, for example. The scent is a bit strong when applied, but as soon as it has dried, this smell has disappeared.
A great mascara that was given to me! I really enjoyed it because it is actually very good! My lashes are much longer and it feels like I have fake lashes! I use it in the morning after daily care, and after applying makeup on my face! With this magnificent mascara I have a voluminous and very beautiful, sensual look! I highly recommend this beautiful mascara!
It was the first time I saw vegan mascara and honestly it's not bad. It doesn't beat some big brand mascara but it does the trick and looks natural on top of that. I recommend it for anyone who wants something natural. And for those who are in favour of vegan products. #nourishednewyear
Opting for a natural look? According to We Are Eves members, this vegan and cruelty-free mascara is the key to success! Honest reviews praise the well-pigmented formula, which provides separated lashes and stays perfectly in place all day long. Want a bit more glam? Apply a second coat—according to Eves members, it won't clump even then!
Is this your ultimate mascara match?
This product really separated my eyelashes and didnt look clumpy.
Coated them well and give fullness and depth. It also gives really longer looking lashes and I didnt feel the need to use false eyelashes on evening as out. Good depth of colour and lasted all day. Easy to remove at night with a cleansing wipe too.
Big time fan of Max Factor mascaras and this one doesn’t disappoint. The large curled wand makes application really easy and doesn’t smudge or end up all over my eyelid! Had lots of compliments whilst wearing and people thought I had fake lashes on. Would definitely recommend as a day to day mascara or even for going out as it can be easily layered for a more dramatic look or lift.
Easy to use. Happy with this purchase and will buy again.Best mascara I have ever used, except for one that I really like that costs three times as much. It coats the lashes well, doesn't clog up or smudge. This is sometimes out of stock so I buy other brands but always end up coming back to this one.
Thought I would give max factor mascara a go having never used it and WOW I won’t look back. This is definitely going to a regular for me. So soft on your eye lashes with great coverage and curl, I also love the colours on the design on the cover.
Would happily recommend.
This is really one of the best mascaras I've ever used!! It stayed seated for a long time (photo is 6 hours after application) and has no lumps. However, it is a thin mascara that I personally like better, but you can always apply multiple layers that also look nice. The mascara also makes my lashes look longer and have more volume because of the applicator.
Eves members have found their match in this Curl Addict Mascara. It's in the name: this mascara delivers beautiful, curled lashes. And according to honest reviews, this mascara truly lives up to its promises, making it more than worth the purchase.
Waterproof mascara that's truly waterproof
This is a very nice mascara!! I'm not into waterproof mascara at all, but I'm number 1 fan after using this mascara for the first time. First of all, it is nice mascara and a very nice brush, so this mascara extends your lashes. It is also nice to use, you have to do it a few times over each other, but the mascara certainly extends 🤩
I definitely recommend this mascara!
I really like mascara, a nice brush to apply it.
You do have to apply it layer by layer, but this works for the volume. Removing this mascara is also not a tragedy, although this mascara is waterproof, it is very quick to remove. So I am very satisfied with this mascara and would definitely buy it again.
I definitely recommend this mascara, it works!
I really liked this mascara! Never actually wear waterproof mascara because it will ruin my lashes, but I tried it for a long time and my lashes are still the same! HAPPY HIHI
I also swam with the mascara and it stays in place all day, great!
Would definitely recommend him.
christiannevandenbosch2004 This is a beautiful mascara, suitable for long lashes! I have very long lashes by myself, which is why they stick together quickly. This is not the case at all with this mascara. It distributes well and gives a lot of volume. In the photo, I applied the mascara to one eye and not to the other. See the difference!! However, two layers have been applied to this photo.
The mascara is not very easy to polish off in the shower. But normal makeup remover is fine!
I had the pleasure of testing this mascara from WeaReeves, but the price is not high in relation to the quality at all. I would definitely buy it again!
With most waterproof mascara, my lashes often clump together. This mascara doesn't bother you at all. I also swam with me every day on vacation and it stays in place very well. However, it is advisable to remove the mascara with an oil remover
Even Eves members who aren't usually fans of waterproof mascara are happy to make an exception for this Bourjois mascara. Why? The brush ensures easy application and keeps lashes nicely separated while also adding extra volume. And it's truly waterproof, according to honest reviews.
Is this the best affordable waterproof mascara?
Perfect product. Very layerable, it lengthens the lashes well and thickens them. Real waterproof effect: I was able to remove it only with micellar water. It does not damage the lashes after application and does not create lumps. The brush does not collect too much product, it is soft and easy to handle. I recommend it to those who have a low budget but want quality products. It has all the characteristics of a great mascara.
Wow! This mascara really surprised me. You probably wouldn't expect a great result for such a small price, but you will get it. The formula is super black, giving immediate volume and length. What I especially like is that it separates my lashes nicely. No spider legs or lumps! I use one layer for a natural look, but two for a real “false lash” vibe. It stays in place all day, without running out or crumbling. And also important: it doesn't irritate my sensitive eyes.
💡 Tip: Use an eyelash curler before applying for extra effect!
#EssenceLashPrincess #FalseLashEffect #BudgetBeauty #HolyGrailMascara #WeAreEves #EvesHonestReview #EssenceLover #DrugstoreMakeup #MascaraMagic #SensitiveEyesFriendly #BeautyReviewNL #LashGoals #TestedByMe
Very good mascara. Lasts for a long time and is waterproof, which is very useful in the summer when you sweat! Definitely recommended! I would definitely recommend this one! I've gone swimming with it a few times (not necessarily underwater) but I'm staying put. It is easy to remove with cotton wool. Very convenient to use!
I've tried a lot of different mascaras, from cheap brands to more expensive variants, but this mascara really stands out. What immediately struck me after the first use was the effect it had on my lashes. They immediately looked a lot longer and fuller, almost like I was wearing fake lashes, but with a natural look. This is exactly the result I've always been looking for. The mascara formula is easy to use. It's neither too wet nor too dry, making it easy to apply without smudging or clumping. Something that often happens with other mascaras, especially when you apply multiple layers. With this mascara, you can easily apply a second or even third layer for extra volume and length, without your lashes sticking together. Personally, I think that's a huge plus. In addition, this mascara gives a subtle shine to the lashes, providing a fresh and open look. It really lets your eyes speak and makes your whole look just that little bit more neat and elegant. I've also noticed that it stays in place throughout the day — it doesn't stain, doesn't crumble and stays in place until I remove it at night. By the way, removing is also easy with a regular makeup remover; you don't have to rub hard. In short: an excellent mascara that does what it promises. My lashes look longer, fuller and more beautiful. I definitely recommend this product to anyone looking for a reliable and quality mascara!
Yes, the title says it all. This has been my holy grail mascara for years. I've worn out so many tubes of these. The waterproof ones, the purple ones and the brown ones are just my favorite mascara. It works well with my lashes and I often use it in combination with another mascara and this is just what works for me. I've tried a number of different mascaras, but I've never bought them as often as this one.
Another waterproof favorite among Eves members is this offering from Essence. 400 Eves members rave about the volume you can achieve with this mascara and how long it stays put without smudging—even in the rain! It's no wonder that some Eves members have been hooked for years.
Low-budget mascara, please
This mascara is really nice and for me it's my new favorite, which I'll definitely buy again later. The brush is very special in shape and ensures that my lashes lift immediately after 1 stroke of mascara. This is also shown in the photo. Really a huge difference! Easy to take off and it doesn't clump. I really can't help but give 5 stars.
A very nice, affordable mascara. The mascara applies black well without lumps. You can build the mascara well without getting spider legs. The mascara stays in place all day without smearing. With a lot of volume and spreads the lashes beautifully.
This mascara isn’t clumpy and literally gives u the volume and length you need for your lashes!! Most mascaras do nothing for my short lashes but after using this one i could see the results after one coating! I couldn't believe my eyes because i never thought my lashes could look so beautiful. Highly recommend.
This mascara was my favorite mascara for many years and I'm absolutely thrilled that I now have it again. The color stays where it should be, on the eyelashes and not anywhere else. Although it is not waterproof, it can withstand a few tears as long as you don't rub against wet lashes. The shipping was also very fast and reliable. I will definitely buy them again
I've tried a lot of mascaras but this one is my favorite one! Every time I'm in the Kruidvat, I buy one more. A friend of mine who loved mascara who sadly passed away would love this one! So are you looking for a new mascara? Then I would definitely recommend this one!
Looking for a mascara under a tenner? Look no further! This mascara from Rimmel London is beloved by Eves members and proves that an affordable mascara can truly be great. The mascara makes your lashes intensely black, beautifully defines each hair, and is easy to build up.
High Rated Mascaras - FINAL VERDICT
Which mascaras suit your makeup preferences best? Are you in the market for a mascara for sensitive eyes or maybe one that will give you all the drama?—Whichever one, we’re all about conscious choice here.
With WAE, upping your mascara collection doesn’t have to be complicated anymore! We are here every week to give you the latest details, from our beauty archives, on our community's highest rated products. Meaning, saving your time, moolah, and stress just got a WHOLE lot easier.
HEY, we wanna hear from you!
If you’ve enjoyed reading the latest beauty reviews, why not pop in your own thoughts and officially join the We Are Eves family? Our virtual beauty gang is always ready for more raw-and-real reviews, and we wanna know what you think! Click the link below to start your journey. We’ve saved a space for you…